That’s exactly what happened a few years ago when the comedian shared a few reflective moments with Jamie Dornan.

Kimmel first asked Dornan about some photos of himself and Billy Murray golfing together.

After they were off the green, Jamie Dornan says he was a bit too starstruck to ask his golf partner to hang out, but that moment did unexpectedly come after a party later that night.

Dornan recalled that he had gotten a little too tipsy and was sneaking off to bed, when the elevator doors to his floor opened to reveal Bill Murray, who instead took the young actor to a hidden bar in the hotel with a balcony overlooking the golf course.

Ultimately, Jamie Dornan decided to wait a few seconds and then sneak off to bed without attempting to interact with Bill Murray inside.

Still, it’s pretty cool to think that Bill Murray could give Dornan such an incredibly memorable moment by just standing with him silently for a couple minutes.

Jamie Dornan appeared on Jimmy Kimmel Live to promote his upcoming sequel Fifty Shades Darker, which comes out in February 2017.

Check out Dornan telling the tale of his night with Bill Murray below.